Jump to content
SiouxSports.com Forum

Transfer Portal 2024-25

forksandspoons

By forksandspoons
in Football

 Share

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 763
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Popular Posts

geaux_sioux
geaux_sioux

We need some posters to enter the portal lol

siouxfb
siouxfb

There is a fire Bubba thread for this conversation and to complain about QB play/reps/etc.  This thread is about the transfer portal. It sounds like we are actively looking for a portal QB which is wh

siouxweet
siouxweet

I am sure Quincy is a great kid.  How many W's did he bring to the football program, not very many and his stat line is non existent.   My point was I hope this new QB brings more than being a nice gu

Posted Images

Nodak78 Grand Master

Nodak78

Posted
Posted
  On 12/25/2024 at 5:48 PM, siouxweet said:

Arch Manning, really? Comparing the number one recruited QB in the country to a backup freshman QB at San Diego State.  My point is there are people on this board that think this kid is the savior and will walk on water.  Let's wait and see as there is a reason he is moving down levels.

Expand  

Eric watched this guy up close the last year.  If Eric wants him, I'm good.

  • Upvote 2
UNDvince97-01 Enthusiast

UNDvince97-01

Posted
Posted
  On 12/25/2024 at 5:45 PM, sioux24/7 said:

Want to spit ball the related positions they’ll be taking?

Expand  

Sure, I'll give it a shot. After some research, here's what I deduced and came up with:

- Washington (S)

- Wyoming (TE)

- Fresno St (LB)

- ODU (EDGE)

- Mankato (RC)

- Augustana (WR)

These are just hypotheticals only and not to be taken seriously.

^dunt chute da mssngr

jdub27 Veteran

jdub27

Posted
Posted
  On 12/25/2024 at 9:24 PM, UNDvince97-01 said:

Sure, I'll give it a shot. After some research, here's what I deduced and came up with:

- Washington (S)

- Wyoming (TE)

- Fresno St (LB)

- ODU (EDGE)

- Mankato (RC)

- Augustana (WR)

These are just hypotheticals only and not to be taken seriously.

^dunt chute da mssngr

Expand  

Wait, no DC....? 

  • Like 1
CMSioux Mentor

CMSioux

Posted
Posted
  On 12/25/2024 at 5:48 PM, siouxweet said:

Arch Manning, really? Comparing the number one recruited QB in the country to a backup freshman QB at San Diego State.  My point is there are people on this board that think this kid is the savior and will walk on water.  Let's wait and see as there is a reason he is moving down levels.

Expand  

The first step here is trusting the talent evaluation skills of our new head coach. 

  • Upvote 3
The Sicatoka Grand Master

The Sicatoka

Posted
Posted
  On 12/25/2024 at 9:24 PM, UNDvince97-01 said:

Sure, I'll give it a shot. After some research, here's what I deduced and came up with:

- Washington (S)

- Wyoming (TE)

- Fresno St (LB)

- ODU (EDGE)

- Mankato (RC)

- Augustana (WR)

These are just hypotheticals only and not to be taken seriously.

^dunt chute da mssngr

Expand  

Do you do mega millions numbers also? Like for Friday’s draw? 

UND08 Rising Star

UND08

Posted
Posted
  On 12/25/2024 at 5:48 PM, siouxweet said:

Arch Manning, really? Comparing the number one recruited QB in the country to a backup freshman QB at San Diego State.  My point is there are people on this board that think this kid is the savior and will walk on water.  Let's wait and see as there is a reason he is moving down levels.

Expand  

I'm not saying he'll walk on water...but he is likely one of the most physically gifted QB's to ever step foot on campus.  Does that translate into All American accolades...of course not!  But, for an obviously talent deficient roster an influx of athletes that can potentially help right away either on the field or pushing others will be much appreciated.

Just because you are on the roster doesn't mean you have a divine right to a spot.  Playing time is earned...and coaching seats warm up too quickly to not put the best players on the field (or find better players if the ones you have aren't good enough to win at a high level).  I wasn't a huge fan of the Schmidt hire...but he's doing what needs to be done with the roster IMO and I'm coming around on things...

  • Upvote 2
Siouxperman8 Mentor

Siouxperman8

Posted
Posted
  On 12/26/2024 at 5:04 PM, UND08 said:

I'm not saying he'll walk on water...but he is likely one of the most physically gifted QB's to ever step foot on campus.  Does that translate into All American accolades...of course not!  But, for an obviously talent deficient roster an influx of athletes that can potentially help right away either on the field or pushing others will be much appreciated.

Just because you are on the roster doesn't mean you have a divine right to a spot.  Playing time is earned...and coaching seats warm up too quickly to not put the best players on the field (or find better players if the ones you have aren't good enough to win at a high level).  I wasn't a huge fan of the Schmidt hire...but he's doing what needs to be done with the roster IMO and I'm coming around on things...

Expand  

Honest question.  Why were you hesitant on the Schmidt hire?

Dustin Veteran

Dustin

Posted
Posted
  On 12/26/2024 at 5:35 PM, Siouxperman8 said:

Honest question.  Why were you hesitant on the Schmidt hire?

Expand  

I'll answer this from my perspective.  I was not overly impressed with his defenses at UND, and it seemed the San Diego SU defenses were also similarly questionable.  But I've been a convert in the period since he was hired with his access to knowledge at the highest level of FBS.    

  • Upvote 3
UND08 Rising Star

UND08

Posted
Posted
  On 12/26/2024 at 5:35 PM, Siouxperman8 said:

Honest question.  Why were you hesitant on the Schmidt hire?

Expand  

 

  On 12/26/2024 at 5:58 PM, Dustin said:

I'll answer this from my perspective.  I was not overly impressed with his defenses at UND, and it seemed the San Diego SU defenses were also similarly questionable.  But I've been a convert in the period since he was hired with his access to knowledge at the highest level of FBS.    

Expand  

What Dustin said...his last 3 years at UND the defense was very "mid" at best.  Somehow it got worse after he left...

And to add to that...I was in the camp that an outside hire would be a nice breath of fresh air into the program.  There were a couple of regional candidates that I liked better that I feel like are on an upward trajectory and would have had an opportunity to be great.  I think a lot of people connotate Eric Schmidt the legendary player with an assumption that he'll automatically succeed as head coach at UND...and I've seen that not be the case quite often.  It seems to me that the top decision he's made as a coach was hitching his wagon to Kalen DeBoer...which was a great decision!

I think he's been a helluva position coach...but the jury is still out in my mind on his ability as a head coach given his history as a coordinator.  That said...I'm glad he recognizes that the talent level has been deficient roster-wide (with obvious bright spots).  It gives me hope that he can get the job done.  Next will be his external staffing hires...

sioux24/7 Grand Master

sioux24/7

Posted
Posted
  On 12/25/2024 at 9:24 PM, UNDvince97-01 said:

Sure, I'll give it a shot. After some research, here's what I deduced and came up with:

- Washington (S)

- Wyoming (TE)

- Fresno St (LB)

- ODU (EDGE)

- Mankato (RC)

- Augustana (WR)

These are just hypotheticals only and not to be taken seriously.

^dunt chute da mssngr

Expand  

Guessing the Augie WR coach would be Malik Bradshaw. Fruechte followed him recently. 

forksandspoons Grand Master

forksandspoons

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Do we hear about the defensive staff by tomorrow? Hoping Schmidt is still on the hunt for some D1 defensive linemen in the portal in the meantime. Yes, a new defensive scheme will be in place, but could use a LB with experience as well. UND lost a good amount to graduation this year

Siouxperman8 Mentor

Siouxperman8

Posted
Posted
  On 12/26/2024 at 6:29 PM, UND08 said:

 

What Dustin said...his last 3 years at UND the defense was very "mid" at best.  Somehow it got worse after he left...

And to add to that...I was in the camp that an outside hire would be a nice breath of fresh air into the program.  There were a couple of regional candidates that I liked better that I feel like are on an upward trajectory and would have had an opportunity to be great.  I think a lot of people connotate Eric Schmidt the legendary player with an assumption that he'll automatically succeed as head coach at UND...and I've seen that not be the case quite often.  It seems to me that the top decision he's made as a coach was hitching his wagon to Kalen DeBoer...which was a great decision!

I think he's been a helluva position coach...but the jury is still out in my mind on his ability as a head coach given his history as a coordinator.  That said...I'm glad he recognizes that the talent level has been deficient roster-wide (with obvious bright spots).  It gives me hope that he can get the job done.  Next will be his external staffing hires...

Expand  

My take is that he now has experience at the highest level of college football.  Hoping that he can parlay what he has learned and the connections he has made to put together a top staff and roster.  

Others had head coaching experience but not at the FCS level or above.  It is a tradeoff and a bit of a crap shoot either way.

  • Upvote 3
petey23 Mentor

petey23

Posted
Posted
  On 12/24/2024 at 2:15 PM, siouxweet said:

Questions I have with this new QB is if he was recruited by these top FBS schools why pick San Diego State and then if the QB1 position is yours for the taking why transfer down to an average FCS program?   These types of transfers don't always pan out.  I remember NDSU a few years back got a kid from VA Tech that was a dumpster fire.   Hoping he isn't Quincy Vaughn 2.0.

Expand  

Well, just speculating. He was recruited by the previous staff and Brady Hoke retired and the new coach brought in new staff after what would have been his redshirt season. Not sure how different the offensive philosophy from one coach to the new staff but may be a factor. 

Devils Enthusiast

Devils

Posted
Posted

This thread reminds me of the time I saw Phil Martelli speak in 2004 or so.  He was the longtime basketball coach at St. Joseph's in Philadelphia and they were a #1 seed that year and made the elite 8.  He won many coach of the year honors that year and he said in the talk I saw "do you think I just figured out how to coach this year, that this was the best job I've ever done as a coach, that's bs."  His point was he had great players (mostly Jameer Nelson and Delonte West who both had successful NBA careers) that year and it all came together.  Coaching is important, but put any coach somewhere with little talent on the team and it will be a struggle.  

  • Upvote 4
AJS Grand Master

AJS

Posted
Posted

For those not aware, we are in the middle of a "dead period" for recruiting, which is from Dec.23 to Jan. 5. No in-person contact with recruits.

  • Upvote 2

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...