FCS Playoffs

[JohnboyND7]

9 hours ago, SlowHand said:

Thats wayyy after the whistle blew and the UIW player pulled the ball away from 49.

Not sure why the whistle blowing would matter. Officials regularly blow a whistle and then sort out who recovered the ball. 

I'm not sure how you can take this very definite position. Earlier you shared a screenshot saying it was the precise moment the whistle blew and 49 is 100% not in possession of the ball. 

 

[SIOUXFAN97]

not that it should matter to play up to the cameras but when the iwu player recovered the fumble (which he did)...he should hold it up or stand up and make the first down signal....sell it to the reviewers

[JohnboyND7]

7 minutes ago, SIOUXFAN97 said:

not that it should matter to play up to the cameras but when the iwu player recovered the fumble (which he did)...he should hold it up or stand up and make the first down signal....sell it to the reviewers

I dont think there was an issue of UIW not being animated that they recovered the football.

[FSSD]

12 hours ago, SlowHand said:

This is exactly when the whistle blew.  Show me which UIW player has the ball.

 

Which Bison player has possession of the ball?  It ain't 49 and you can see the ICW player with an arm under the pile.

[sioux rube]

UIW had a handful I’d charge ces to put the game away and they failed. Bison May have won but UIW gave it to them. Bison had one completion but somehow won 

[SIOUXFAN97]

1 hour ago, JohnboyND7 said:

I dont think there was an issue of UIW not being animated that they recovered the football.

the sidelines yes...but the guy that recovered it wasn't too hyped...shouldn't matter but do the simba cam with the ball?

[geaux_sioux]

3 hours ago, Hawkster said:

Do you still think the dome wasn't much of an advantage for them last night?   I'm pretty sure that place was worth more than the 3 point margin of victory.

Nothing compared to what it was. Not even close.

[Hawkster]

48 minutes ago, geaux_sioux said:

Nothing compared to what it was. Not even close.

So in your mind, do we still lose to Weber if the game was in the Alerus?

[geaux_sioux]

50 minutes ago, Hawkster said:

So in your mind, do we still lose to Weber if the game was in the Alerus?

Irrelevant to the previous discussion. However, it’s pretty obvious that we are Tarzan at home and Jane on the road.

[Kab]

Neutral sites in warm weather climates?

crazy to play in Bozeman or brookings this time of,year, really adds to the player  experience the ncaa is so worried about.

[Hammersmith]

5 hours ago, The Sicatoka said:

Can anyone refute or explain those pics? 

Those pics are worthless. The endzone camera shows absolutely nothing other than the ball moving around. In that last image, the hand in front of the ball is from the top UIW player, not UIW 20. It doesn't show who established possession first. The real question is whether NDSU 49 got his elbow around the ball before UIW 20 snuck it out from underneath him. I honestly don't know from the one angle that we've seen that shows it. There were at least six possible cameras that had some sort of angle on the play and we only saw three of them(and one of those three was not zoomed or slowed). 

I'm not going to post screenshots, but if you can get the game on the ESPN player, go to 3:16:17/3:33:54. If you advance the frames slowly using the spacebar, you can see the nose of the football start to peek out to the left of NDSU 49's arm that's braced on the ground. Nobody has established possession yet. This is happening after all three of the pics you were referring to. If you advance the video slowly, you can see UIW 20 begin to insert his right arm under 49's body to get the ball, but 49 quickly cuts that off by pulling his elbow in. At that point, you can see the other nose of the ball peeking out of the crook in 49's elbow. 20's left hand and arm are also underneath 49's body trying to pull the ball out from under him. Before either can be determined from this angle, the ball disappears from view.

UIW 20 eventually retrieves the ball from under NDSU 49, but it's possible 49 was able to get his elbow around the ball before that and secure it for a moment. If that happened, the play was dead at that instant and nothing that happens later means anything. I honestly don't know who recovered the ball first, but neither does anyone else here. Since replay called it confirmed, I have to assume one of the other angles clearly shows 49's elbow around the ball before 20 yanks it away.

[Nodak78]

EWU has the red turf.  The Jackrabbits has a white turf.

[SiouxHawkGuy]

Bowl game somewhere warm seems nice

[SIOUXFAN97]

30 minutes ago, Hammersmith said:

Those pics are worthless. The endzone camera shows absolutely nothing other than the ball moving around. In that last image, the hand in front of the ball is from the top UIW player, not UIW 20. It doesn't show who established possession first. The real question is whether NDSU 49 got his elbow around the ball before UIW 20 snuck it out from underneath him. I honestly don't know from the one angle that we've seen that shows it. There were at least six possible cameras that had some sort of angle on the play and we only saw three of them(and one of those three was not zoomed or slowed). 

I'm not going to post screenshots, but if you can get the game on the ESPN player, go to 3:16:17/3:33:54. If you advance the frames slowly using the spacebar, you can see the nose of the football start to peek out to the left of NDSU 49's arm that's braced on the ground. Nobody has established possession yet. This is happening after all three of the pics you were referring to. If you advance the video slowly, you can see UIW 20 begin to insert his right arm under 49's body to get the ball, but 49 quickly cuts that off by pulling his elbow in. At that point, you can see the other nose of the ball peeking out of the crook in 49's elbow. 20's left hand and arm are also underneath 49's body trying to pull the ball out from under him. Before either can be determined from this angle, the ball disappears from view.

UIW 20 eventually retrieves the ball from under NDSU 49, but it's possible 49 was able to get his elbow around the ball before that and secure it for a moment. If that happened, the play was dead at that instant and nothing that happens later means anything. I honestly don't know who recovered the ball first, but neither does anyone else here. Since replay called it confirmed, I have to assume one of the other angles clearly shows 49's elbow around the ball before 20 yanks it away.

lot of words for...fumble...recovered by iwu.  simple. 

[Sioux94]

Davis for SDSU was damn lucky, if there was a better angle he would have blown a TD

[Hammersmith]

21 minutes ago, SIOUXFAN97 said:

lot of words for...fumble...recovered by iwu.  simple. 

Small number of words for ... not smart enough to refute any point. Simple.

[SIOUXFAN97]

3 minutes ago, Hammersmith said:

Small number of words for ... not smart enough to refute any point. Simple.

nothing to refute...simple play...fumble...and a recovery for the cards. next 

[Nodak78]

Jacks in control.  28-6  2nd qtr

[ChrisUND1]

Montana State getting absolutely rolled and embarrassed by SDSU.  36-9 halfway through 3rd quarter.  

[Sioux94]

MSU making UND defense look pretty stout! SDSU has a TD on every possession 

[Sioux94]

Hope SDSU keeps rolling them. Good for a MVFC team to destroy a top Big Sky team. Big fluffy getting put in it's place. 

[SIOUXFAN97]

9 minutes ago, Sioux94 said:

Hope SDSU keeps rolling them. Good for a MVFC team to destroy a top Big Sky team. Big fluffy getting put in it's place. 

mvfc is down this year!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!             (boths teams in title game are mvfc)

[Oxbow6]

Turf at SDSU looks like my driveway 

[Siouxfan11]

Right now I’m pretty happy I bought SDSU hoodie, after they beat the bison in October, to wear around here in Fargo.

[Sioux94]

43 minutes ago, Siouxfan11 said:

Right now I’m pretty happy I bought SDSU hoodie, after they beat the bison in October, to wear around here in Fargo.

Hoping you are even more excited to wear in about three weeks!