Transfer Portal 2024-25

[GoodGood]

Oh no people deleting posts about the transfer QB. We got our guy!

[HoopsFan03]

4 minutes ago, GoodGood said:

Oh no people deleting posts about the transfer QB. We got our guy!

Noticed that too! 

Sad to see but at least we got our guy!! 

[SiouxFan100]

11 minutes ago, GoodGood said:

Oh no people deleting posts about the transfer QB. We got our guy!

What’s happening?

[SiouxFan100]

I don’t know if I should be happy concerning QBs?  Do we have a capable qb transferring in?

[gfhockey]

Whose deleting posts

[gfhockey]

Dad said he hasn’t signed yet but good sign the dads here checking out the favilities

 

donee have our guy

[CMSioux]

2 hours ago, jdub27 said:

 

Pepperidge Farms remembers...

 

 

We'll take a little credit for this one. Getting to know his parents and grandmother and making sure they got the best barbeque ribs in the tailgate lot.

[jdub27]

On 12/18/2024 at 8:48 AM, jdub27 said:

I don't. But I don't believe they have interest in the SDSU transfer.
Probably fair to say the new HC has a good idea on whether he would be a good fit or not.

Happily wrong on this one if it is accurate and he's the guy. Heard a few other names floated, but like I said, new HC has a good idea on how he would be for a fit.

[UNDvince97-01]

28 minutes ago, jdub27 said:

Happily wrong on this one if it is accurate and he's the guy. Heard a few other names floated, but like I said, new HC has a good idea on how he would be for a fit.

We did not have any interest in the SDSU kid that went to Wisconsin.

The other SDSU kid however...

[forksandspoons]

From Tupou’ata-Johnson's bio: Chose the Aztecs over offers from Arizona State, BYU, Florida State, Kansas, Oregon, Pittsburgh, Nevada, and San Jose State.

[gundy1124]

2 minutes ago, forksandspoons said:

From Tupou’ata-Johnson's bio: Chose the Aztecs over offers from Arizona State, BYU, Florida State, Kansas, Oregon, Pittsburgh, Nevada, and San Jose State.

This kid can be a legitimate game changer for UND. He looks nothing like our QBs past and present.  I hope the flow and reports are true in that he will soon be a F'n Hawk.

[SIOUXFAN97]

2 minutes ago, gundy1124 said:

This kid can be a legitimate game changer for UND. He looks nothing like our QBs past and present.  I hope the flow and reports are true in that he will soon be a F'n Hawk.

he has zero chance of playing for UND if Simon is here in the fall....no chance!!!!!!!

[forksandspoons]

2 minutes ago, gundy1124 said:

This kid can be a legitimate game changer for UND. He looks nothing like our QBs past and present.  I hope the flow and reports are true in that he will soon be a F'n Hawk.

100%! Him and a couple new WRs would be dangerous (got one, now to get another)!

[The Sicatoka]

SDSUred QB1 (O'Neil) is going to Wisconsin. 

Why is this JT'-J fellow in the portal when QB1 is open? 

[SiouxFan100]

How do I say this? I find no need to rub it into players who might be replaced by better transfers in. Something like that. Not saying anyone has.

[SIOUXFAN97]

1 minute ago, The Sicatoka said:

SDSUred QB1 (O'Neil) is going to Wisconsin. 

Why is this JT'-J fellow in the portal when QB1 is open? 

"shows him simon's one hoppers and said this was our starter last year"

 

[gundy1124]

6 minutes ago, forksandspoons said:

100%! Him and a couple new WRs would be dangerous (got one, now to get another)!

These things can snowball in a good way.  Land the QB, WR target sees that and joins the party.  Then hopefully some DT's with nicknames like Tank and Big Snacks hop on board.

[jdub27]

11 minutes ago, The Sicatoka said:

SDSUred QB1 (O'Neil) is going to Wisconsin. 

Why is this JT'-J fellow in the portal when QB1 is open? 

Possible fallout from Jayden Denegal from UMichigan transferring in with 2 years of eligibility left?
Not sure what their depth chart looks like with all the movement going on.

Like seeing upgrades in competition at key spots! One more WR and a few on the D-side to keep it going!

[iramurphy]

3 hours ago, GoodGood said:

The Jensen kid didn’t have good high school stats. USC doesn’t know how to recruit the QB position 

  I assume you and a couple other experts have far more experience than I with regards to recruiting  college players and how evaluations and recruiting have evolved over the years. 
 

I responded to a post regarding a qb in the portal from USC that another was very impressed with and wished we could get a guy like that. When I went on the USC site, the guy hadn’t played there. He had been at a couple of schools before USC including a JC. I could not see anything that would warrant USC interest. I checked his record (stats) and it appeared he had been ok at the JC level. I pointed out we had a couple of guys whose HS careers appeared to have been more impressive based on their stats. I didn't,  and still don't,  see anything that would get us excited about him even though he was on the team at USC.  I also admitted that he could be a hidden gem.  I didn’t comment on USC’s ability to recruit QB’s but I would bet a lot that he wasn’t put on the team with the idea he would be in the mix for playing time. 

I wasn’t joking,  I made an observation.  The USC connection was impressive until I found nothing going back including his HS years that would indicate he would be an impact player for us much less USC. Without film or a conversation with USC staff, that’s kind of an initial evaluation  

So those who think he could be a difference maker (maybe he could), tell me where I’m wrong. 
 

 

 

[The Sicatoka]

6 minutes ago, jdub27 said:

Possible fallout from Jayden Denegal from UMichigan transferring in with 2 years of eligibility left?
Not sure what their depth chart looks like with all the movement going on.

I found AJ Duffy from FSU going to SDSUred. 

How does anyone track movement in the portal era? 

[GoodGood]

13 minutes ago, iramurphy said:

  I assume you and a couple other experts have far more experience than I with regards to recruiting  college players and how evaluations and recruiting have evolved over the years. 
 

I responded to a post regarding a qb in the portal from USC that another was very impressed with and wished we could get a guy like that. When I went on the USC site, the guy hadn’t played there. He had been at a couple of schools before USC including a JC. I could not see anything that would warrant USC interest. I checked his record (stats) and it appeared he had been ok at the JC level. I pointed out we had a couple of guys whose HS careers appeared to have been more impressive based on their stats. I didn't,  and still don't,  see anything that would get us excited about him even though he was on the team at USC.  I also admitted that he could be a hidden gem.  I didn’t comment on USC’s ability to recruit QB’s but I would bet a lot that he wasn’t put on the team with the idea he would be in the mix for playing time. 

I wasn’t joking,  I made an observation.  The USC connection was impressive until I found nothing going back including his HS years that would indicate he would be an impact player for us much less USC. Without film or a conversation with USC staff, that’s kind of an initial evaluation  

So those who think he could be a difference maker (maybe he could), tell me where I’m wrong. 
 

 

 

Who’s better at evaluating QBs: Lincoln Riley or IraMurphy? Some are saying it’s a toss up 

[HoopsFan03]

20 minutes ago, GoodGood said:

Who’s better at evaluating QBs: Lincoln Riley or IraMurphy? Some are saying it’s a toss up 

I’m rolling with Ira!!! 

[Oxbow6]

If you as a FCS program get a QB who is interested in dropping down and joining your program from a P5 conference you basically say....when can you get here. Those kids are 100% worth the roster spot to see if they can stick or not. No need to over think this. If he routinely throws a 25 yard out 18 yards you have your answer pretty quick.

[McBuckets]

25 minutes ago, GoodGood said:

Who’s better at evaluating QBs: Lincoln Riley or IraMurphy? Some are saying it’s a toss up 

Maybe some people should watch the actual film (even if it is practice tape) instead of being box score warriors

[iramurphy]

I never said there isn’t a spot for the guy on the roster. I disagreed that we would be “salivating” over this guy if he would come here.  

There isn’t anything impressive about his performance so far. Didn’t throw a pass at USC.Its obvious he wasn’t in their plans. He  left  at BYU without playing, was an ok JC QB and is a couple years older than most juniors. That doesn’t mean he couldn’t be a “hidden gem”.

I stated that without reviewing film, there was nothing else to go by and I’m not pretending to evaluate this guy beyond a Quick Look at what’s easily available.  Other than the fact that he was on the roster at USC, what would get us excited about him?