Transfer Portal 2023

[ND-fan]

Recruiting even high regarded recruits are still crap shoot unless your big time FBS schools even then many fail to make grade. We from outside don’t Know how these quarterbacks are performing and time effort they are putting in and they have tremendous amount athletic ability but now requires mental ability to understand offenses and defense do it on quick basis. This requires time varies from player to player.Romfo has had to show this because being walk on from small school behind  of number of highly recruited players still to be considered shows he has ability to play the position. Second he has had to do this with two different offensive coordinators.Finally Jerry may eventually win this position but many of you forget here is Jerry is still only freshman I don’t see to many freshman playing significant minutes playing time for young quarterbacks is starting when they are sophomores. Trey should have been one getting playing time this year but he chose to leave and find position he would get more playing time this told me he probably going down division to get this and he didn’t think he could be starting quarterback.  NDSU quarterback Cam Miller has been exception to this but look he is being considered For NFL again in there recent condition.  I would like for us recruit NFL caliber quarterback but we need to reach next level where players of that level would consider coming here. I even think that NDSU may not be able to recruit that level talent now because FCS and FBS have separated because of money flowing to FBS. Even if FCS team does recruit player of that level he will be scooped up by FBS with money they can offer players today.
 The problem with this team wasn’t on the offense this year but the defense side we had at beginning of year when everyone was healthy at best average defense. There are number of good defense players but just not enough of them. We need to recruit bigger up front people like we have the offensive side. Second we also need faster and quicker people on backside and outside plus having more depth. The offense needs to improve also with faster and quicker people on receiving end 75% of receiving was dependent on Boe. We also need to have tight ends that can be offensive threat. The change in FBS roster sizes I believe is going to be opportunity for UND to build program through transfers this coming year. Second FCS is basically coming down to Valley and Big Sky conferences. The majority of FCS teams are not going to fund support football to level of these two conferences especially top of both these conferences. The next several years are going to be interesting where all this shakes out.

[shep]

Having heard the hierarchy of UND football talk about making the playoffs as the program goal, one needs to ask:

What kind of player wants to come to a place where making the playoffs is the highest goal?

 

[Oxbow6]

37 minutes ago, shep said:

Having heard the hierarchy of UND football talk about making the playoffs as the program goal, one needs to ask:

What kind of player wants to come to a place where making the playoffs is the highest goal?

 

Trust the process........

[geaux_sioux]

17 hours ago, shep said:

Having heard the hierarchy of UND football talk about making the playoffs as the program goal, one needs to ask:

What kind of player wants to come to a place where making the playoffs is the highest goal?

 

I get what you’re saying but they’ve never said that was their highest goal. Pretty confident a national title is the highest goal and was even stated by players in fall camp. 

[90siouxfan]

Seems like Chaves Chaves was likely speaking about minimum accomplishment and not the season goal.  But if fits the narrative, off with his head.  But to be clear,  Chaves Chaves & Nappy Bubba being shown the door would be an awesome early Christmas present, and the earlier the better.

[shep]

1 hour ago, geaux_sioux said:

I get what you’re saying but they’ve never said that was their highest goal. Pretty confident a national title is the highest goal and was even stated by players in fall camp. 

I may have missed his point. Thanks for the correction.

[nd1sufan]

On 11/28/2024 at 5:38 PM, ND-fan said:

Recruiting even high regarded recruits are still crap shoot unless your big time FBS schools even then many fail to make grade. We from outside don’t Know how these quarterbacks are performing and time effort they are putting in and they have tremendous amount athletic ability but now requires mental ability to understand offenses and defense do it on quick basis. This requires time varies from player to player.Romfo has had to show this because being walk on from small school behind  of number of highly recruited players still to be considered shows he has ability to play the position. Second he has had to do this with two different offensive coordinators.Finally Jerry may eventually win this position but many of you forget here is Jerry is still only freshman I don’t see to many freshman playing significant minutes playing time for young quarterbacks is starting when they are sophomores. Trey should have been one getting playing time this year but he chose to leave and find position he would get more playing time this told me he probably going down division to get this and he didn’t think he could be starting quarterback.  NDSU quarterback Cam Miller has been exception to this but look he is being considered For NFL again in there recent condition.  I would like for us recruit NFL caliber quarterback but we need to reach next level where players of that level would consider coming here. I even think that NDSU may not be able to recruit that level talent now because FCS and FBS have separated because of money flowing to FBS. Even if FCS team does recruit player of that level he will be scooped up by FBS with money they can offer players today.
 The problem with this team wasn’t on the offense this year but the defense side we had at beginning of year when everyone was healthy at best average defense. There are number of good defense players but just not enough of them. We need to recruit bigger up front people like we have the offensive side. Second we also need faster and quicker people on backside and outside plus having more depth. The offense needs to improve also with faster and quicker people on receiving end 75% of receiving was dependent on Boe. We also need to have tight ends that can be offensive threat. The change in FBS roster sizes I believe is going to be opportunity for UND to build program through transfers this coming year. Second FCS is basically coming down to Valley and Big Sky conferences. The majority of FCS teams are not going to fund support football to level of these two conferences especially top of both these conferences. The next several years are going to be interesting where all this shakes out.

The kid backing up Cam Miller right now, Nathan Hayes, is 6’4, very athletic and has a rocket for an arm(reportedly three the baseball in the low 90’s in high school. You would think UND would find someone like that whe would rather play right away than back up for 3 years before they get a shot. 

[UND1983]

Just now, nd1sufan said:

The kid backing up Cam Miller right now, Nathan Hayes, is 6’4, very athletic and has a rocket for an arm(reportedly three the baseball in the low 90’s in high school. You would think UND would find someone like that whe would rather play right away than back up for 3 years before they get a shot. 

We don’t recruit anything over 5’11

[LH Golfer]

Any guess when the portal entrant list will start to trickle out?

 

[AJS]

1 minute ago, LH Golfer said:

Any guess when the portal entrant list will start to trickle out?

 

Any time. There won’t be a list that comes out from the school, you’ll see individuals post on social media once they enter. 

[SIOUXFAN97]

On 11/29/2024 at 7:48 PM, UND1983 said:

We don’t recruit anything over 5’11

and from 9 man fb only too

[Hawkster]

30 minutes ago, AJS said:

Any time. There won’t be a list that comes out from the school, you’ll see individuals post on social media once they enter. 

I figure that no news on this front is good news.