San Diego @ UND 9/21/24

[UND1983]

12 minutes ago, GoodGood said:

UND completed 5 passes against a team that doesn’t have scholarships 

*UND scored 41 points vs a team that doesn't have scholarships but reduces tuition the exact same amount that a partial scholarship would

[Oxbow6]

Who can UND beat moving forward with a first half passing like Saturday or 5 completions in a game? 

[GoodGood]

Just now, Oxbow6 said:

Who can UND beat moving forward with a first half passing like Saturday or 5 completions in a game? 

Probably powerhouses Murray and Indiana State 

[The Sicatoka]

Failing to prepare is preparing to fail. 

We see shortcomings but it's working for now. 

If IF the OC is doing his job he's working hard to improve every QB on the roster to have options when W becomes L. 

[homer]

1 minute ago, Oxbow6 said:

Who can UND beat moving forward with a first half passing like Saturday or 5 completions in a game? 

Do we average 6 ypc in those games?

[Oxbow6]

2 minutes ago, GoodGood said:

Probably powerhouses Murray and Indiana State 

But only if we are a 4 score favorite at home??  What's the Murray line?

[Oxbow6]

7 minutes ago, The Sicatoka said:

Failing to prepare is preparing to fail. 

We see shortcomings but it's working for now. 

If IF the OC is doing his job he's working hard to improve every QB on the roster to have options when W becomes L. 

Shortcomings...arm strength and more importantly accuracy. Not things that are a easy mid season fix. He can definitely make plays with his feet. Why not some true ROPs? Anyone watch GB last two weeks? 

[geaux_sioux]

Just now, Oxbow6 said:

Shortcomings...arm strength and more importantly accuracy. Not things that are an easy mid season fix. He can definitely make plays with his feet. Why not some true ROPs? Anyone watch GB last two weeks? 

I am very curious to see how we do things against good teams. I’m still thinking we may be saving Romfo running true RPOs for when we need it. Time will tell.

[HoopsFan03]

1 minute ago, Oxbow6 said:

Shortcomings...arm strength and more importantly accuracy. Not things that are a easy mid season fix. He can definitely make plays with his feet. Why not some true ROPs? Anyone watch GB last two weeks? 

We do run RPO's but Romfo never keeps it. Kind of defeats the purpose of having a QB that can't throw a football but supposedly has great legs if he never keeps the ball on those RPO's...

[GoodGood]

1 minute ago, HoopsFan03 said:

We do run RPO's but Romfo never keeps it. Kind of defeats the purpose of having a QB that can't throw a football but supposedly has great legs if he never keeps the ball on those RPO's...

I think teams are deathly afraid of his 11 rushes for 10 yards the last two weeks 

[UND Football Fan]

10 minutes ago, GoodGood said:

I think teams are deathly afraid of his 11 rushes for 10 yards the last two weeks 

My hope (it is a hope) we see more QB runs in the bigger games. NDSU typically in the past did not run the QB unless it was against a better team.  There was a few times during the few games where it looked if he kept the handoff he could hit the edge and get some yards. 

[CMSioux]

14 hours ago, Sioux94 said:

Here are his stats for the year. 55% completion percentage and 5 INT's with 4TD's in 5 games. 

Yet we can't question whether or not the Wisconsin player of the year with all of the measurable and a PWO from Wisconsin, son of a coach might not give us a better chance to win? 

I was, have, and will root for Romfo to do well. But if you look at the stats and watch the games.....it hasn't been good. Yes we won the last 3 games, that doesn't mean we couldn't have won them with Jerry starting.  

Im sure Jerry could run the RPO and hand off 95% of the time. I don't like to knock a kid, especially from ND, but so far appears to be the poorest passing QB that UND has had in 40 years.  Not sure how you could even dispute that so far....but hey let's roll with him because our team is to fragile to handle us making a change at QB.  Did every other UND QB that didn't start until they were a junior or senior get to use the excuse......"they haven't played in a real game in 4 years". I don't remember that excuse ever being made in the past, usually it made us feel good that a new starting QB was an upper classmen and has been in the system.

I will be rooting for Romfo and his passing to improve,  because unless he gets injured he is obviously not leaving the field.  For the most part I backed and stood up for Tommy because there were definitely a few Tommy haters, and while Tommy had a few limitations he was pretty damn good. 

 

I'm still on board with the ones that see the players every day in practice and in meetings to make the decisions. 

[UND1983]

29 minutes ago, Oxbow6 said:

Who can UND beat moving forward with a first half passing like Saturday or 5 completions in a game? 

Montana apparently

[GoodGood]

1 minute ago, UND1983 said:

Montana apparently

Already got us playing Montana in the playoffs? 

[UND1983]

1 minute ago, GoodGood said:

Already got us playing Montana in the playoffs? 

What? 

[GoodGood]

Just now, UND1983 said:

What? 

I read the original question and it’s says moving forward. I don’t believe we play Montana again in the regular season 

[UND1983]

Just now, GoodGood said:

I read the original question and it’s says moving forward. I don’t believe we play Montana again in the regular season 

ok

[UND-FB-FAN]

1 hour ago, The Sicatoka said:

3 wins > 5 completions 

queue Al Davis ... just win baby ... 

 

53 minutes ago, The Sicatoka said:

Failing to prepare is preparing to fail. 

We see shortcomings but it's working for now. 

If IF the OC is doing his job he's working hard to improve every QB on the roster to have options when W becomes L. 

No question. Just need to prepare for when passing game will be of greater necessity. It’s a matter of when, not if. 

[Irish]

Wow - a lot of pushback from my post - No, I didn't watch the QB competition in camp.  No, I'm not saying Romfo didn't win the starter's job in pre-season.  What I am saying is that we have had 4 non-conference games and his highly recruited back-up has played exactly 1 snap - a kneel down - this after the other highly recruited QB saw the writing on the wall and is transferring.  And after watching Romfo pass for 11 yards with 2 picks in the first half he didn't get a sniff.    That, in my opinion, is extremely short sighted and sends a poor message to our back-ups.  Vintage stubborn Bubba though.  We will soon get into some games where short-arming simple outs and swing passes will cost us and no one else has any game experience.  Not great roster management.  And much of Romfo's running success is due to our great O line play.  

[Irish]

58 minutes ago, The Sicatoka said:

Failing to prepare is preparing to fail. 

We see shortcomings but it's working for now. 

If IF the OC is doing his job he's working hard to improve every QB on the roster to have options when W becomes L. 

Not sure how giving the back-up 1 kneel down snap in 4 non-conference games is working hard to prepare every QB..  Very short-sighted.

 

[F'n Hawks]

1 minute ago, Irish said:

Wow - a lot of pushback from my post - No, I didn't watch the QB competition in camp.  No, I'm not saying Romfo didn't win the starter's job in pre-season.  What I am saying is that we have had 4 non-conference games and his highly recruited back-up has played exactly 1 snap - a kneel down - this after the other highly recruited QB saw the writing on the wall and is transferring.  And after watching Romfo pass for 11 yards with 2 picks in the first half he didn't get a sniff.    That, in my opinion, is extremely short sighted and sends a poor message to our back-ups.  Vintage stubborn Bubba though.  We will soon get into some games where short-arming simple outs and swing passes will cost us and no one else has any game experience.  Not great roster management.  And much of Romfo's running success is due to our great O line play.  

To be fair he did hit a long throw for a TD the play after the 2nd interception. Props to Freuchte for having trust in him and scheming Bo open. I do agree that these simple throws need to start being made or else we need to look at Kaminski. 

[Big Green]

A question we will never know the answer to but, if Jerry would have played the 2nd half of the Montana game would be have won?  I was hoping they would switch QBs a half time, but they didn't and UND won.  

I keep thinking back to Tom Millers article before the starting QB was selected and he said Romfo and Trey had 40% chance to win the staring QB spot and Jerry was at 20%.  If Tom sees it and he has watch a lot more practice than any of us, maybe Jerry is not ready yet.  If Trey would have stuck around maybe he would have gotten a chance.  Another thing we will never know.

 

[HoopsFan03]

6 minutes ago, Big Green said:

A question we will never know the answer to but, if Jerry would have played the 2nd half of the Montana game would be have won?  I was hoping they would switch QBs a half time, but they didn't and UND won.  

I keep thinking back to Tom Millers article before the starting QB was selected and he said Romfo and Trey had 40% chance to win the staring QB spot and Jerry was at 20%.  If Tom sees it and he has watch a lot more practice than any of us, maybe Jerry is not ready yet.  If Trey would have stuck around maybe he would have gotten a chance.  Another thing we will never know.

 

So now we're using Tom Miller as justification for why Romfo keeps starting and we give our backup QB 0 snaps??

Wow!! 

[sioux24/7]

I don’t want to read through all of this but has there been any explanation on why it took so long to get Ziebarth in the game? Felt like he was maybe given a quarter suspension or something? Or dealing with injury and we were hoping to hold him out?

On the Romfo-Jerry thing, all I’m going to add is that it was malpractice not giving Jerry some more live reps in the Idaho State game. 

[Siouxperman8]

Not a Romfo basher at all.  The game is pretty fast the first few games you play in and he'll get better as it slows down for him. 

That said - the postgame radio show pointed out that against better teams we'll need to be able to convert on some 3rd and 8 and not over or under throw the receivers like he's done a few times.