siouxfan512 Posted Wednesday at 03:57 PM Posted Wednesday at 03:57 PM 17 hours ago, HockeyHawk said: I really hope it’s not Smaby there must surely be better candidates, and in reality we need more fresh talent than the worn road of UND alums. This program needs an injection of energy and excitement. Like Shaw? That was a disaster too. Saying we need a non-UND guy is as dumb as saying we do need a UND guy. Just find the right guy, regardless of where he is from. For the record, I'm not saying that is Smaby ... just more of a general statement. I was hoping for the long shot with Herter... 4 Quote
siouxkid12 Posted Wednesday at 04:00 PM Posted Wednesday at 04:00 PM 2 minutes ago, siouxfan512 said: Like Shaw? That was a disaster too. Saying we need a non-UND guy is as dumb as saying we do need a UND guy. Just find the right guy, regardless of where he is from. For the record, I'm not saying that is Smaby ... just more of a general statement. I was hoping for the long shot with Herter... serious question but what do you think was wrong with Shaw? Quote
siouxfan512 Posted Wednesday at 04:03 PM Posted Wednesday at 04:03 PM 1 minute ago, siouxkid12 said: serious question but what do you think was wrong with Shaw? If I recall correctly, and I could be wrong (its been known to happen a lot), wasn't he in charge of the power play and wasn't it just god awful? Not sure how much he contributed. There was a reason UND moved on from him. Then again, maybe Berry was the problem then too... 1 Quote
Popular Post sioux24/7 Posted Wednesday at 04:19 PM Popular Post Posted Wednesday at 04:19 PM I get the thought process of saying a guy that played a position has to coach that position but don’t you think these guys have been around the game long enough where even if they are a “trained” defenseman, they can coach a forward? I don’t know, maybe I’m naive but I think once you’ve been in the game long enough you can handle more than just your position group. 1 5 Quote
SpudsSioux Posted Wednesday at 04:23 PM Posted Wednesday at 04:23 PM 16 minutes ago, siouxfan512 said: If I recall correctly, and I could be wrong (its been known to happen a lot), wasn't he in charge of the power play and wasn't it just god awful? Not sure how much he contributed. There was a reason UND moved on from him. Then again, maybe Berry was the problem then too... Shaw was on the coaching staff that won a national championship, too. Who knows how good or bad he was, but you can only do so much with the skill you have to work with and there was a noticeable drop off the next couple years. If Shaw was the only problem, we wouldn't have seen more of the same over the course of the next 8 years, in my opinion. 1 1 Quote
SpudsSioux Posted Wednesday at 04:25 PM Posted Wednesday at 04:25 PM 4 minutes ago, sioux24/7 said: I get the thought process of saying a guy that played a position has to coach that position but don’t you think these guys have been around the game long enough where even if they are a “trained” defenseman, they can coach a forward? I don’t know, maybe I’m naive but I think once you’ve been in the game long enough you can handle more than just your position group. I agree. I remember guys that played for the Force when Herter was there and they often talked about how good he was at skill development stuff (and that included forwards). I know it's a pipe dream and he's probably not in the mix/didn't apply anyway, but if Herter got it, I would have zero worries that he would be able to coach forwards. 1 Quote
siouxforce19 Posted Wednesday at 04:28 PM Posted Wednesday at 04:28 PM 2 minutes ago, SpudsSioux said: Shaw was on the coaching staff that won a national championship, too. Who knows how good or bad he was, but you can only do so much with the skill you have to work with and there was a noticeable drop off the next couple years. If Shaw was the only problem, we wouldn't have seen more of the same over the course of the next 8 years, in my opinion. He was brought on to run our power play and the national championship team had about a 19% power play conversion. Talent dropped off in the years to follow but the fact that the power play on the 2016 team wasn’t great is pretty surprising. 1 Quote
SpudsSioux Posted Wednesday at 04:49 PM Posted Wednesday at 04:49 PM 6 minutes ago, siouxforce19 said: He was brought on to run our power play and the national championship team had about a 19% power play conversion. Talent dropped off in the years to follow but the fact that the power play on the 2016 team wasn’t great is pretty surprising. Interesting. I didn't realize it wasn't higher in 2016. Easy to forget when the end result worked out. Like I said, I don't know whether he was good or bad, but I know that getting rid of him certainly didn't solve the puzzle as it's been more of the same over the last 8 years. Quote
tnt Posted Wednesday at 05:03 PM Posted Wednesday at 05:03 PM 31 minutes ago, siouxforce19 said: He was brought on to run our power play and the national championship team had about a 19% power play conversion. Talent dropped off in the years to follow but the fact that the power play on the 2016 team wasn’t great is pretty surprising. Didn't have Stecher and LaDue the following year, but they did have Wolanin and Poolman, along with Gersich, Boeser and Jost. That's 5 guys that saw some time in the NHL. Quote
The Sicatoka Posted Wednesday at 05:07 PM Posted Wednesday at 05:07 PM Arguably one of the best DCs in NFL history (Steve Spagnuolo) played offense, WR, in college. Quote
dustnyou Posted Wednesday at 05:43 PM Posted Wednesday at 05:43 PM Someone remind me what position Scotty Bowman played.… oh that’s right, he never did. Next question Quote
siouxkid12 Posted Wednesday at 06:03 PM Posted Wednesday at 06:03 PM 1 hour ago, siouxforce19 said: He was brought on to run our power play and the national championship team had about a 19% power play conversion. Talent dropped off in the years to follow but the fact that the power play on the 2016 team wasn’t great is pretty surprising. Same could be said about Karl and being brought on as a goalie coach but he got to stay. Ever sense he came on board we haven't been able to develop a goalie, and we utilized the portal too often. Quote
ChadR Posted Wednesday at 06:12 PM Posted Wednesday at 06:12 PM There is a reason why Shaw hasn't been involved in hockey since he got fired. 1 Quote
SIOUXELEVENS Posted Wednesday at 06:25 PM Posted Wednesday at 06:25 PM Any idea who applied , who made the cut ? Quote
SIOUXFAN97 Posted Wednesday at 06:28 PM Posted Wednesday at 06:28 PM 16 minutes ago, ChadR said: There is a reason why Shaw hasn't been involved in hockey since he got fired. bubs been bad mouthing him too....? Quote
Siouxperdouper Posted Thursday at 12:01 AM Posted Thursday at 12:01 AM SIOUXFAN97 Posted 5 hours ago 5 hours ago, ChadR said: There is a reason why Shaw hasn't been involved in hockey since he got fired. bubs been bad mouthing him too....? Source? Quote
SIOUXFAN97 Posted Thursday at 12:44 AM Posted Thursday at 12:44 AM 42 minutes ago, Siouxperdouper said: SIOUXFAN97 Posted 5 hours ago 5 hours ago, ChadR said: There is a reason why Shaw hasn't been involved in hockey since he got fired. bubs been bad mouthing him too....? Source? 110 cherry st Quote
The Sicatoka Posted Thursday at 01:31 PM Posted Thursday at 01:31 PM Thursday and not a peep. Stunning. Starting to believe it's a guy with a team still playing. Quote
DL Sioux Posted Thursday at 01:34 PM Posted Thursday at 01:34 PM 2 minutes ago, The Sicatoka said: Thursday and not a peep. Stunning. Starting to believe it's a guy with a team still playing. Plus no Tail Numbers! 1 Quote
ChadR Posted Thursday at 01:48 PM Posted Thursday at 01:48 PM 17 minutes ago, The Sicatoka said: Thursday and not a peep. Stunning. Starting to believe it's a guy with a team still playing. Correct. Smaby. Quote
RhettRingers Posted Thursday at 01:57 PM Posted Thursday at 01:57 PM Just a rumor I heard but sounds like its Smaby and he's flipping McMorrow from Denver. Not a very reliable source but he has been right a few times. 1 Quote
gfhockey Posted Thursday at 02:17 PM Posted Thursday at 02:17 PM Believe my source told me it was smaby a few days ago Quote
siouxfan512 Posted Thursday at 02:17 PM Posted Thursday at 02:17 PM Just now, gfhockey said: Believe my source told me it was smaby a few days ago You sure you weren't just talking to yourself in the mirror again? JK! Quote
gfhockey Posted Thursday at 02:19 PM Posted Thursday at 02:19 PM 1 minute ago, siouxfan512 said: You sure you weren't just talking to yourself in the mirror again? JK! Go look I announced ut Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.