Nothing about Parise's career screams "Hall of Fame". At least with Tkachuk you have some argument (I still don't think so though) on being a HOF player, as 500 goals and 1000 points are no easy feat.
The Hall of Fame is for players like Alex Ovechenkin, Jaromir Jagr, Gordy Howe, Wayne Gretzky, etc. and to water it down with players like Parise is just an embarrassment to those players, IMO.
I am guessing that A. You were in a frat and paid for your friends or B. A college athlete stole your girlfriend. Either way, basing someone's "attitude" because of an off campus fight means nothing.
I don't think he had an attitude problem while here at UND. He could've been coddled under Berry and when a new coach doesn't do that, you get a negative outcome.