Jump to content
SiouxSports.com Forum

Recommended Posts

Posted

He has two feet down before falling on the ground. If this is overturned, I'll rescind my earlier Dallas Cowboy conspiracy theory comments...because obviously it's a Green Bay conspiracy to get the Packers to the Super Bowl so State Farm can make money on Aaron Rodgers commercials.

:-)
Posted

I don't like Dex Bryant but he goes up and gets ball and took 3 steps, knee hit ground then lost control when he landed with hand out stretched. Might be I don't know how many steps necessary before you would be considered a ball carrier but I would have thought that was catch and if defender wasn't in contact, a fumble then recovered. First Fb game I remember watching was Packers Eagles early 60's and have been long time Packers fan but I think we got a break. Was Cowboys fan for 9 yrs when son in law with Cowboys but no matter who you like this is a great game.

Posted

Excited to hear the Dallas conspiracy experts after that overturned call....

Easy. Packers vs Cowboys is a pick 'em because both teams have a large following around the country.

LOL @ Cobb...smart play.

Posted

The Cowboys now know how the Lions felt last week it sure looked like Dez had control and took 3 steps. I think this is more a bad rule than bad call the whole completing the full process thing is stupid just like it was when it took away a TD from Calvin Johnson against Chicago years back.

Posted

I don't like Dex Bryant but he goes up and gets ball and took 3 steps, knee hit ground then lost control when he landed with hand out stretched. Might be I don't know how many steps necessary before you would be considered a ball carrier but I would have thought that was catch and if defender wasn't in contact, a fumble then recovered. First Fb game I remember watching was Packers Eagles early 60's and have been long time Packers fan but I think we got a break. Was Cowboys fan for 9 yrs when son in law with Cowboys but no matter who you like this is a great game.

Media ref says you forget steps cuz receiver going to ground so it was incomplete and good call. Didn't matter that he took 3 steps, Howie Long also said 3 steps and they said he had possession but he was going to ground so he has to control to ground which he didn't.

Posted

Media ref says you forget steps cuz receiver going to ground so it was incomplete and good call. Didn't matter that he took 3 steps, Howie Long also said 3 steps and they said he had possession but he was going to ground so he has to control to ground which he didn't.

 

The problem I have with that call is he had the ball with both hands then switched it to one and reached for the endzone while taking more steps...Perriera says he didn't reach enough? Doesn't having a ball and moving it to one hand and reaching AT ALL show some kind of possession? This seems like a bull$%!# call, and I hate the Cowboys.

Posted

Media ref says you forget steps cuz receiver going to ground so it was incomplete and good call. Didn't matter that he took 3 steps, Howie Long also said 3 steps and they said he had possession but he was going to ground so he has to control to ground which he didn't.

So let's assume Dez was falling over the goal line when that happened...is that a TD because he has crossed the imaginary plane of the goal line?

Posted

So let's assume Dez was falling over the goal line when that happened...is that a TD because he has crossed the imaginary plane of the goal line?

Nope,just like Calvin Johnsons catch in the endzone was ruled incomplete.

Posted

Hope the pack wins next week also Denver but then im for old maning

 

 

Let's hope the next game is as good as the first, you know everyone in the league offices want Manning vs. Brady 2015.

Posted

Let's hope the next game is as good as the first, you know everyone in the league offices want Manning vs. Brady 2015.

That would be ok if old maning wins

Posted

So let's assume Dez was falling over the goal line when that happened...is that a TD because he has crossed the imaginary plane of the goal line?

No, same reasoning. Because he was " going to the ground" he has to control ball after hitting ground.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...