Why is it an either-or? If a transfer is better than at least 2 QBs currently on the roster, bring him in. If a HS recruit has potential to start in 3 years, bring him in. Recruiting, especially at the QB position, needs to consider the future in addition to immediate need.
We need a HS recruit with the potential to start down the road in this class. 1 in the last 4 classes (5 if they punt again this year) is bad for the future of this team. Coaching staff needs to get it done.