Had the same problem in football, every year there was one game that saved him - until it didn't happen. Individual talent seems to be our problem year after year.
St John's can be more attractive than NSIC especially if you consider students at that level are playing for enjoyment and a free education. Yes, they don't offer athletic scholarships, but surprising how many of their top athletes quality for academic scholarships. SJU is top 10 NAIA every year.