Jump to content
SiouxSports.com Forum

D-1 Survey Says...


CDog

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 153
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Exactly the point I was trying to hint at.

I'm telling you now: they only contacted hockey ticket holders. And it was done on purpose.

That's my speculation.

I was a part of this survey and was contacted as a season ticket holder for football. All of the questions I answered referred directly to foootball, level of support if a move occurred, likelihood of attending road games, etc.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Show 'em the money;

show 'em a conference;

you'll be amazed how quickly a tune change.

Money - Go Sioux and Alumni - :0

Conference - Football - GWFC

Basketball - Mid-con (toward end of transition years), possibility - immediately - United Basketball Alliance.

Soccer - United Soccer Conference

Swimming & Diving - possible mid-con affiliate?

Given Grand Forks ND for a base, the "nearby" conferences are the Big Sky, Mid-con/GWFC, and (huge stretch) Gateway/Mo Valley.

Big Sky may expand. Mid-con is DEFINITELY going to expand, and Gateway/Mo Valley several years away from expanding.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was a part of this survey and was contacted as a season ticket holder for football. All of the questions I answered referred directly to foootball, level of support if a move occurred, likelihood of attending road games, etc.

I'm glad to have been proven wrong.

I'm still suspicious, though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I find these result unbelievable. If this is followed through with it might as well be a death sentence for every other sport on campus other than hockey. It's unfathomable that a majority of the "stakeholders" in UND have decided that we are to become a second rate university in ND. I'm speechless.

Quite to the contrary - the only sport that would benefit would be football. Ask the once proud Bison Womens Basketball, volleyball, or softball teams. What do you think would happen to both Sioux basketball teams, track, baseball, volleyball, soccer? The move up to DI for these teams is a killer. This is just from a comptition aspect. How do you think we would fund the move - apparently we are broke now even with attendence at record levels for hockey, football, and women's basketball. The move up would be a train wreck for most programs.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Quite to the contrary - the only sport that would benefit would be football. Ask the once proud Bison Womens Basketball, volleyball, or softball teams. What do you think would happen to both Sioux basketball teams, track, baseball, volleyball, soccer? The move up to DI for these teams is a killer. This is just from a comptition aspect. How do you think we would fund the move - apparently we are broke now even with attendence at record levels for hockey, football, and women's basketball. The move up would be a train wreck for most programs.

Imagine how much worse the bottom line will look if attendance drops because the casual sports fan heads south to Fargo or if corporate donations dry up because everyone wants to support the D-1 institution towards our south. No doubt those sports will struggle, but they'll struggle even more when they're budgets are cut because we're losing our fan base. Plus it's only a matter of time before women's basketball starts losing recruits to full rides from NDSU and SDSU like football and men's basketball. It's also only a matter of time before these recruiting losses start hurting us on the playing field and then how will that affect attendance and the availability of funds. By staying D-2 you're effectively selling out every sport that competes with the SU's for athletes or donations.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Quite to the contrary - the only sport that would benefit would be football. Ask the once proud Bison Womens Basketball, volleyball, or softball teams. What do you think would happen to both Sioux basketball teams, track, baseball, volleyball, soccer? The move up to DI for these teams is a killer. This is just from a comptition aspect. How do you think we would fund the move - apparently we are broke now even with attendence at record levels for hockey, football, and women's basketball. The move up would be a train wreck for most programs.

Speaking of Soccer, the Bison's women's team has done quite well.

The volleyball program hit a snag, true, but I have no doubt they'll bounce back. Not expecting DI championships, but I think they'll make the field of 64 eventually.

Women's basketball had a rough year. But they will be in the NCAA DI tournamant. No doubt UND would be able to as well.

How about NDSU men's basketball? Yeah, they did pretty good didn't they?

Softball, well, it's tough when you have to play on the road for 90% of the season. Not sure if this sport will continue on at NDSU. Perhaps because of title IX.

I have no doubt that attendance for basketball and football would increase at UND against DI competition.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

- apparently we are broke now even with attendence at record levels for hockey, football, and women's basketball. The move up would be a train wreck for most programs.

That is an inaccurate statement. Football attendance is great, but it is not at a record level. When NDSU moved up, they saw a ~15% increase in football attendance, and SDSU about a 30% increase. And I'm sorry to say that interest in women's basketball at UND could be on the decline. The attendance is way, way off from their all-time highs, and that is despite going 34-1 and playing in a brand new beautiful facility (which BTW if anyone hasn't been there is a fantastic place to watch a basketball game). The biggest reason for the low attendance is because of the competition we are playing. I was at the women's game against Mayville St. That was money well spent :D:0

I have no doubt that attendance for basketball and football would increase at UND against DI competition.

I agree. I think basketball attendance would struggle early on (as it has for NDSU) unless of course we have a conference right away, but in either scenario, it would go up in the end, and it will for NDSU too.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes, some of the other sports will struggle early on. It will be part of a growing process for those programs. But why can't those other programs improve down the road and eventually become contenders in their conferences? Heck, even the football team will have an adjustment period to deal with. It's called competing at the highest level that you possibly can. And UND CAN compete at D1 and D1-AA and do quite well in the near future.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes, some of the other sports will struggle early on. It will be part of a growing process for those programs. But why can't those other programs improve down the road and eventually become contenders in their conferences? Heck, even the football team will have an adjustment period to deal with. It's called competing at the highest level that you possibly can. And UND CAN compete at D1 and D1-AA and do quite well in the near future.

Aside from swimming & diving, most of UND's non-revenue sports struggle now in DII. Personally, I'd rather struggle against Minnesota or Kansas, than Emporia St. or Shippensburg.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm surprised that no one has brought up this paragraph that was in this Herald article today:

UND's survey asked people to rate the move on a scale of zero to 10, with zero meaning the school had no business making the move, and 10 meaning UND should jump to Division I whatever it takes. The average score was 5.61 for students, 5.45 for season ticketholders, 4.43 for employees and 3.14 for faculty.

This certainly indicates to me that the students and season ticket holders are pro D-I, all things considered.

Also, I think it's reasonable to assume that more season ticket holders for hockey were surveyed than basketball or football simply because there are more season tickets sold for hockey. Now I'm not saying that all the people that are hockey-only ticket holders were cool on a move, but clearly there is a percentage that simply don't care one way or another about whether or not the rest of the sports are D-I (I realize this is purely anecdotal, but just click on a random thread in the hockey forum and look at all of the users with 100s of posts that have never posted on anything but hockey). I'm sure if only basketball and football ticket holders were surveyed, the results would have been much more favorable towards D-I.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Many of the hockey season ticket holders and football season ticket holders are the same people.

Yes, some certainly are. But (I believe) there are at least three times as many hockey season ticket holders as there are for football. Obviously most hockey ticket holders do not have season tickets for multiple sports.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm surprised that no one has brought up this paragraph that was in this Herald article today:

This certainly indicates to me that the students and season ticket holders are pro D-I, all things considered.

Also, I think it's reasonable to assume that more season ticket holders for hockey were surveyed than basketball or football simply because there are more season tickets sold for hockey. Now I'm not saying that all the people that are hockey-only ticket holders were cool on a move, but clearly there is a percentage that simply don't care one way or another about whether or not the rest of the sports are D-I (I realize this is purely anecdotal, but just click on a random thread in the hockey forum and look at all of the users with 100s of posts that have never posted on anything but hockey). I'm sure if only basketball and football ticket holders were surveyed, the results would have been much more favorable towards D-I.

Yeah, that actually isn't too bad. Especially if you look at how most of the questions are phrases having 2 options: 1. move RIGHT NOW or 2. don't move. Seems that there is actually a sizeable chuck of the pie that would take the third option if it was offered: make the move when conditions are right (not blindly like NDSU has been percieved as doing).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Many of the hockey season ticket holders and football season ticket holders are the same people.

And many of the hockey season ticket holders are also Bison fans in other sports or fans who don't even realize that UND has sports other than hockey.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Looks like your hometown newspaper and that survey has given Kupchella all the cover he needs to pass on the DI move.

http://www.grandforks.com/mld/grandforks/n...on/14549989.htm

... there's almost no appetite for the change-first, find-the-money-and-a-conference-later approach that NDSU took.

That article is saying what some of us have been saying (and observed thanks to others) all along:

Cost.

Conference.

Answer those and there's the answer.

Ultimately, nothing's changed.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Would you be angry if UND moved to DI and anounced that some of the resources that would've gone to hockey will now go to help the football and basketball teams with the transition?

Your question should be: Do you wanna sacrafice basketball and other teams for you football team (in IAA where it belongs) because those others sports have no serious risk of ever winning a championship like they do in D2.

Okay maybe ndsu's estrogen, er, equestrian, or whatever it is.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Your question should be: Do you wanna sacrafice basketball and other teams for you football team (in IAA where it belongs) because those others sports have no serious risk of ever winning a championship like they do in D2.

Okay maybe ndsu's estrogen, er, equestrian, or whatever it is.

No way do we sacrifice basketball.

I think NDSU men's basketball is eventually going to do what Northern Iowa is doing now.

The other sports, I hope they do well, but I don't follow them that much.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...