FBS Playoff Reform

[Kab]

Just divide the p 4 from  g whatever 

‘let each group decide their playoff system

only let the g teams play fcs teams so the big dogs need to play only big dogs and all games to be done by Jan 1st 

[Big Green]

7 minutes ago, JohnboyND7 said:

Notre Dame didn't really do it to themselves. On Tuesday, they were told (along with the rest of America) that they were in. On Sunday, they were told that they were not...even though nothing changed in that time. The committee made it clear in the past few weeks that they had directly compared ND with Miami and that Notre Dame was their selection. Frankly, I think the only reason they aren't in is because Virginia lost to Duke, and the committee was afraid of leaving out a "P4" conference entirely.

Now did they lose games they coulda shoulda won? Sure. Agreed on that 100%. But make no mistake, this exposed a really major flaw in the system.

By not being in a Conference they was always relying on the Committee to give them an at large bid. 

Probably right about the reason Miami got in.  Nothing was final until Sunday.  The Committee can change there mind up until that time.

 

[SIOUXFAN97]

26 minutes ago, JohnboyND7 said:

This aint happening. They aren't going to give the G6 40% of the playoff field nor should they. 

they do in basketball and it's worked for decades....?

[SIOUXFAN97]

22 minutes ago, Kab said:

Just divide the p 4 from  g whatever 

‘let each group decide their playoff system

only let the g teams play fcs teams so the big dogs need to play only big dogs and all games to be done by Jan 1st 

only ndac LOVES lesser division titles....dumb.

were the best of the lessers....bring on 'Bama!

so dumb

 

[JohnboyND7]

Just now, SIOUXFAN97 said:

they do in basketball and it's worked for decades....?

Basketball and football are not the same and I think we all understand that.

[SIOUXFAN97]

1 minute ago, JohnboyND7 said:

Basketball and football are not the same and I think we all understand that.

they aren't ....but they should be....what's different?

baseball, hockey, basketball???? all 1 division?

why football?

[SIOUXFAN97]

a or b?

[fightingsioux4life]

2 hours ago, JohnboyND7 said:

This aint happening. They aren't going to give the G6 40% of the playoff field nor should they. 

The P4 would probably want to ban all G6 schools from being eligible for the playoff at all. That ain't happening either. Nor should it.

Notre Dame probably thinks they should get special treatment like they did in the Bowl Coalition/Bowl Alliance/BCS era. That ain't happening either. Nor should it.

People will probably continue to pretend that Ohio and Ohio State belong in the same subdivision. But that doesn't make it true.

If the P4 doesn't like G6 schools crashing "their" party, they should just do what they have threatened to do for several years: Set up their own subdivision. Until then, stop the griping.

[JohnboyND7]

2 minutes ago, fightingsioux4life said:

 

Notre Dame probably thinks they should get special treatment like they did in the Bowl Coalition/Bowl Alliance/BCS era. That ain't happening either. Nor should it.

 

It is indeed happening. And it should.

[BIGSIOUX]

All this is fixed if they just don’t share the field as it sits the weeks before.  Just something for tv to talk about.  

[SIOUXFAN97]

37 minutes ago, BIGSIOUX said:

All this is fixed if they just don’t share the field as it sits the weeks before.  Just something for tv to talk about.  

love the selection shows for those few weeks....

[cberkas]

They don’t need special treatment. At some point all the P4 schools/conferences should tell Notre Dame get in a conference or no CFP. 

No 3 loss teams should be in the playoffs BYU (11-2) should be in and Alabama should be out.