MoSiouxFan Posted November 13 Share Posted November 13 2 hours ago, Johnny Five said: The ultimate connundrum. Send your kid away early and give up having them in the house as teenagers? I mean sometimes I'd love to kick my kids outta the f'ing house...but then you send them to college and you wish they were around more often. I think there's 3-4 families from Bismarck who sent their FR kids away before they even played a single HS game. To me, that's nuts. If a kid comes in and dominates HS hockey, now then you have something to consider for your SR season. We always hear about "playing up" and increasing the competition. But then rewind back to mites, peewees, squirts and we teach kids and families to play where you have the puck on your stick more often. Seems to be contradictory in itself. I'm glad Mattern made it. I think that sends a fantastic message. Play in ND, stay home with your friends and family, take advantage of off season programs and activites. You don't need to leave to make it. Trust me on that one, a good friend of mine from freaking Hallock has 2 boys playing for Augie that stayed start to finish...and their schedule isn't exactly murderer's row. From my personal experience, the kids that "make it" could've made it from home. Harper Bentz left Bismarck for Moorhead. You could tell in Mites that kid was different. Max Vig, you could tell from a young age he had something special. And there's plenty of others. Honestly, there's a right and a wrong for each family and we've seen it work and seen it not work. At the end of the day, everyone has to make a decision they feel is best for their family. It's unfortunate that in this day and age with video and off season opportunities, the label still exists. Good rundown on where things are. You only get one shot at raising those kids, so I think that it's a good idea to have them stay home through high school. It may set their development back a year or so, but I think that having them at home through high school is the greater good. Just my $0.02. 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Johnny Five Posted November 13 Share Posted November 13 Avery Matt from CHS girls announces D1 commitment to Holy Cross. Matt joins Brenna Curl (CHS to Maine - 24 grad) and Kenleigh Fischer (North and committed to St. Thomas - 26 grad) as girls who stayed home. Hopefully that's another trend that continues for girls hockey as there is a lot of upcoming talent within the borders. 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Speez Posted November 13 Share Posted November 13 7 hours ago, gfhockey said: Rather get 70 games in a year vs 28 also many of those 70 games against top aa Minnesota competition gfhockey got that right. Most ND peewee and bantam teams have already played 10-15 games. ND high school hockey is still 2 weeks away from even starting. Big mistake in not starting AAA hockey in ND. The better kids that are leaving would be able to stay home and get the 70-80 game schedule. That would let the next tier of kids to move up to play high school instead of quitting or playing Midget Gold. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Frozen4sioux Posted November 13 Author Share Posted November 13 4 minutes ago, Speez said: gfhockey got that right. Most ND peewee and bantam teams have already played 10-15 games. ND high school hockey is still 2 weeks away from even starting. Big mistake in not starting AAA hockey in ND. The better kids that are leaving would be able to stay home and get the 70-80 game schedule. That would let the next tier of kids to move up to play high school instead of quitting or playing Midget Gold. Not sure I agree on the ND based AAA... I agree it should be allowed to happen, it's 'Merica you want to start a program and people want to pay to participate go ahead, freedom right! But I think the argument that then can "stay home" is false. They can stay home if it's in fargo.... for Fargo kids.... is what people mean when they say that. That doesn't help nor solve the ND High school vs AAA/Jr's issue. Nor does it work to run the all year long Team ND model and just get together from all across the state and play on the weekends without practices, training and structure. Unfortunately we are a victim of the reality of geography, participation, and preference of our athletes and administrators vs other sports. The only hope is to make some improvements at the NDHSAA level for the best interest of the kids. That's not going to happen. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Speez Posted November 14 Share Posted November 14 9 minutes ago, Frozen4sioux said: Not sure I agree on the ND based AAA... I agree it should be allowed to happen, it's 'Merica you want to start a program and people want to pay to participate go ahead, freedom right! But I think the argument that then can "stay home" is false. They can stay home if it's in fargo.... for Fargo kids.... is what people mean when they say that. That doesn't help nor solve the ND High school vs AAA/Jr's issue. Nor does it work to run the all year long Team ND model and just get together from all across the state and play on the weekends without practices, training and structure. Unfortunately we are a victim of the reality of geography, participation, and preference of our athletes and administrators vs other sports. The only hope is to make some improvements at the NDHSAA level for the best interest of the kids. That's not going to happen. And that's why the better kids are leaving ND because as you say "That's not going to happen" Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Frozen4sioux Posted November 14 Author Share Posted November 14 21 minutes ago, Speez said: And that's why the better kids are leaving ND because as you say "That's not going to happen" Some stay, family is more important to some, but it's tough to say no. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Frozen4sioux Posted November 14 Author Share Posted November 14 56 minutes ago, Speez said: ND high school hockey is still 2 weeks away from even starting. 39 minutes ago, Frozen4sioux said: The only hope is to make some improvements at the NDHSAA level for the best interest of the kids. That's not going to happen. 28 minutes ago, Speez said: And that's why the better kids are leaving ND because as you say "That's not going to happen" When the administrators look you in the eye or write about how they understand the issue but then unanimously vote to deny the recommendations of the hockey committee 16 YEARS in a row (only 16 cause that's just how far back one can see votes) That tells you everything you need to know about the GiveAShit factor NDHSAA has for kids who play hockey. It's literally telling them to GTFO! Add the ability for HS teams to go to a weekend tourney or showcase two more weekends now your up to 35 games and the chance to play some better competition, then keep the spring/fall Team ND stuff Boom 50-60 games and more exposure through the season while staying at home. Continue to grow the development of coaches and practice at the youth level through ADM and generation by generation, the culture will improve. But for those in high school now it's too late. and for the love of God let a kid come BACK from a AAA program. Stop punishing kids who try to better or challenge themselves! 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
siouxweet Posted November 14 Share Posted November 14 On 11/10/2024 at 9:18 PM, MoSiouxFan said: Is Bob Gillen not doing the high school hockey website anymore? No updates since March, with the season apparently starting this week. He has a new website www.highschoolhockeynd.com Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
sioux rube Posted November 14 Share Posted November 14 Kenleigh Fischer from North/South made Team USA U18 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MoSiouxFan Posted November 14 Share Posted November 14 1 hour ago, siouxweet said: He has a new website www.highschoolhockeynd.com Thanks! (I did see that recently). Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SiouxperDave Posted November 15 Share Posted November 15 Three former NDHS players were recently selected to play in the 2025 Winter World University Games from January 13-23 in Torino, Italy. * Jay Buchholz - Davies * Dillon Kuntz - GFC * Paige Ackerman - Minot https://www.achahockey.org/23-players-named-to-2025-united-states-womens-national-university-team https://www.achahockey.org/23-players-named-to-2025-united-states-mens-national-university-team 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Brim006 Posted Sunday at 02:40 AM Share Posted Sunday at 02:40 AM I can’t argue that a longer season, more non-con games, and more games in general wouldnt help keep more kids home. In my opinion more games need to happen so hopefully they can make it happen. But overall I don’t get all the doom and gloom chatter about ND boys high school hockey. Kids leaving early isn’t exclusive to just ND HS hockey…it’s happening everywhere. For the most part it’s a silly trend due to parents getting crazier and hockey turning into a money game. Kids leaving early doesn’t pan out the majority of the time, especially kids who leave early for something other than NAHL or higher…and very much especially for kids who leave way early and have no business doing so. Just to pull a few of you back away from the ledge, check out the list of kids who stayed in NDHSH THROUGH their Jr or even Sr year over the “recent” years and ended up playing D1. I even excluded some who played NDHSH for 2-3 years and left after SO year. Also, keep in mind ND only has 20 teams so it seems to be a pretty strong flow IMO given the low population. I’m sure I’ve missed a few…but it still doesn’t look so bad just letting your kid stay at home when you look at this list. If he’s good enough they’ll find him and he’ll get an opp in Juniors when he’s physically bigger and stronger and ready for it after high school. I’d imagine if we were able to compile the list of kids who left too early and ruined their chances it would be a LONGGG list. GFRR SR 2008 - Eric Meland - Princeton GFRR SR 2008 - Alex Simonson - Omaha GPR JR 2008 - Chad Demers - Air Force GFC JR 2010 - Casey Purpur - N mich GFC JR 2010 - Paul Ladue - UND *NHL GFC SR 2011 - Johnny Simonson - UND BC JR 2011 - Aaron Nelson - Mankato GFRR SR 2013 - Jon Lizzotte - SCSU *NHL BC SR 2013 - Alex Rauhauser - Bowling G GPR SR 2014 - Jade Miller - UMD BHS SR 2014 - Jared Spooner - Mankato GFC SR 2017 - Grant Nelson - N mich BC JR 2018 - Kirkland Irey - bemidji GFRR SR 2018 - Mason Salquist - SCSU GFC SR 2018- Kaleb Johnson - UND GFC SR 2019 - Cole Hanson- Maine FD JR 2019 - Cade Stibbe - ASU GFC SR 2020 - Will Howard - Augustana GFC SR 2020 - William Lawson-Body - Ak F FSS SR 2021 - Zach Sandy - UMD Missing a few ???? WF SR 2025 - Bryce Mattern - ASU commit 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Speez Posted Sunday at 10:24 PM Share Posted Sunday at 10:24 PM "Missing a few????" I sure hope so. 21 players in 16 years doesn't sound like a great accomplishment for ND hockey to me. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Brim006 Posted Sunday at 10:35 PM Share Posted Sunday at 10:35 PM 33 minutes ago, Speez said: "Missing a few????" I sure hope so. 21 players in 16 years doesn't sound like a great accomplishment for ND hockey to me. That’s just kids who have went D1 even after playing through high school in ND without leaving early. The point is that you don’t have to leave early to still obtain good opportunities. Spare me about MN high school hockey and how many more go D1 from there when they have 21x the amount of players and teams…it’s probably a very similar amount that go D1 percentage wise. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Speez Posted Sunday at 11:06 PM Share Posted Sunday at 11:06 PM 23 minutes ago, Brim006 said: That’s just kids who have went D1 even after playing through high school in ND without leaving early. The point is that you don’t have to leave early to still obtain good opportunities. Spare me about MN high school hockey and how many more go D1 from there when they have 20x the amount of players and teams…and probably a very similar amount that go D1 percentage wise. I never mentioned MN hockey. I think it's ridiculous that ND tries to copy MN hockey for the reasons you mentioned. I'm a proponent of AAA hockey to afford the better players the opportunity to play 80 games against better competition to improve their abilities to move up to a higher level without leaving home. 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ksixpack Posted Monday at 04:51 AM Share Posted Monday at 04:51 AM On 11/16/2024 at 8:40 PM, Brim006 said: I can’t argue that a longer season, more non-con games, and more games in general wouldnt help keep more kids home. In my opinion more games need to happen so hopefully they can make it happen. But overall I don’t get all the doom and gloom chatter about ND boys high school hockey. Kids leaving early isn’t exclusive to just ND HS hockey…it’s happening everywhere. For the most part it’s a silly trend due to parents getting crazier and hockey turning into a money game. Kids leaving early doesn’t pan out the majority of the time, especially kids who leave early for something other than NAHL or higher…and very much especially for kids who leave way early and have no business doing so. Just to pull a few of you back away from the ledge, check out the list of kids who stayed in NDHSH THROUGH their Jr or even Sr year over the “recent” years and ended up playing D1. I even excluded some who played NDHSH for 2-3 years and left after SO year. Also, keep in mind ND only has 20 teams so it seems to be a pretty strong flow IMO given the low population. I’m sure I’ve missed a few…but it still doesn’t look so bad just letting your kid stay at home when you look at this list. If he’s good enough they’ll find him and he’ll get an opp in Juniors when he’s physically bigger and stronger and ready for it after high school. I’d imagine if we were able to compile the list of kids who left too early and ruined their chances it would be a LONGGG list. GFRR SR 2008 - Eric Meland - Princeton GFRR SR 2008 - Alex Simonson - Omaha GPR JR 2008 - Chad Demers - Air Force GFC JR 2010 - Casey Purpur - N mich GFC JR 2010 - Paul Ladue - UND *NHL GFC SR 2011 - Johnny Simonson - UND BC JR 2011 - Aaron Nelson - Mankato GFRR SR 2013 - Jon Lizzotte - SCSU *NHL BC SR 2013 - Alex Rauhauser - Bowling G GPR SR 2014 - Jade Miller - UMD BHS SR 2014 - Jared Spooner - Mankato GFC SR 2017 - Grant Nelson - N mich BC JR 2018 - Kirkland Irey - bemidji GFRR SR 2018 - Mason Salquist - SCSU GFC SR 2018- Kaleb Johnson - UND GFC SR 2019 - Cole Hanson- Maine FD JR 2019 - Cade Stibbe - ASU GFC SR 2020 - Will Howard - Augustana GFC SR 2020 - William Lawson-Body - Ak F FSS SR 2021 - Zach Sandy - UMD Missing a few ???? WF SR 2025 - Bryce Mattern - ASU commit From just GF Central, missing Kanta - Army Holt - Maine Hodgson - Bentley Grant Johnson - Northern Michigan A few in the pipeline that will/may as well… Coleman RR - UMass commit Carter Sproule RR NAHL Bydal RR NAHL Dillon Kuntz GFC - UNLV (rumored to go D1 very soon). Of all those names, I believe all stayed through senior year of high school except Bydal, who left after Jr year. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Brim006 Posted Monday at 06:00 PM Share Posted Monday at 06:00 PM 13 hours ago, ksixpack said: From just GF Central, missing Kanta - Army Holt - Maine Hodgson - Bentley Grant Johnson - Northern Michigan A few in the pipeline that will/may as well… Coleman RR - UMass commit Carter Sproule RR NAHL Bydal RR NAHL Dillon Kuntz GFC - UNLV (rumored to go D1 very soon). Of all those names, I believe all stayed through senior year of high school except Bydal, who left after Jr year. Wow nice, thanks for sharing! I had Grant listed but missed all others. I’m assuming I’m missing several from WF and Fargo as well. I knew about Kuntz at UNLV, so it’ll be interesting to see what happens with that program! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ksixpack Posted Monday at 08:12 PM Share Posted Monday at 08:12 PM 2 hours ago, Brim006 said: Wow nice, thanks for sharing! I had Grant listed but missed all others. I’m assuming I’m missing several from WF and Fargo as well. I knew about Kuntz at UNLV, so it’ll be interesting to see what happens with that program! I am sure there are others from around the state as well…Bob Gillian used to list ND high school hockey alumni and where they are playing now on his website but I don’t think he does that anymore. I wish he would, It was cool to follow their careers. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Frozen4sioux Posted Tuesday at 05:07 PM Author Share Posted Tuesday at 05:07 PM From the new site www.highschoolhockeynd.com 2024-25 Boys State Pre-Season Coaches Poll Team PTS 1st Place 2023-24 Record 1-G.F. Central 349 11 22-4-0 2-G.F. Red River 349 7 21-6-0 3-Minot 307 1 17-9-1 4-W.F. Packers 278 15-9-0 5-Fargo North 267 1 20-7-0 6-Bismarck Century 258 20-7-0 7-Fargo South/Shanley 257 13-14-0 8-W.F. Sheyenne 250 10-13-1 9-Fargo Davies 237 7-17-0 10-Bismarck Legacy 230 18-7-1 11-Mandan 160 11-11-0 12-Devils Lake 159 8-15-1 13-Jamestown 148 11-13-0 14-Dickinson 135 16-10-0 15-Grafton/Park River 107 6-16-0 16-Williston 93 8-14-1 17-Bottineau/Rugby 91 9-15-0 18-Bismarck High 63 1-21-0 19-May-Port Area 37 6-15-0 20-Hazen/Beulah 31 6-16-0 2024-25 West Region Boys Pre-Season Coaches Poll Team PTS 1st Place 2023-24 Record 1-Minot 79 7 17-9-1 2-Bismarck Century 73 3 20-7-0 3-Bismarck Legacy 62 18-7-1 4-Mandan 54 11-11-0 5-Jamestown 47 11-13-0 6-Dickinson 46 16-10-0 7-Williston 32 8-14-1 8-Bottineau/Rugby 29 9-15-0 9-Bismarck High 19 1-21-0 10-Hazen/Beulah 9 6-16-0 2024-25 East Region Boys Pre-Season Coaches Poll Team PTS 1st Place 2023-24 Record 1-Grand Forks Central 71 7 22-4-0 2-Grand Forks Red River 67 3 21-6-0 3-West Fargo Packers 53 15-9-0 4-West Fargo Sheyenne 43 10-13-1 5-Fargo North 37 20-7-0 6-Fargo South/Shanley 35 13-14-0 7-Fargo Davies 32 7-17-0 8-Devils Lake 22 8-15-1 9-Grafton/Park River 9 6-16-0 10-May-Port Area #10 Seed--Does not play Region Schedule Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Frozen4sioux Posted Tuesday at 05:21 PM Author Share Posted Tuesday at 05:21 PM WDA just flat out misses on Legacy and Mandan that's your battle for 2/3 right there. Legacy could easily develop into a top 5 at state finish, they'll have 2 lines and pushing a 3rd by February, with some young talent. If Mandan doesn't Mandan, they'll be back at state this year, they have enough depth. 4-7 roll the dice on who shows up on any given night. EDC looks right where I'd say it is top 2, then WF solid 3, after that more murky until goalies establish themselves to see what's what. Should be interesting to watch and definitely more parity this year, not as skilled as years past, by a long shot, but a good chance for some programs to get back to state. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Johnny Five Posted 4 hours ago Share Posted 4 hours ago Games of interest coming up this weekend, before the chaos starts... Girls Friday: CHS at EGF - non con, Mandan at L/B, North at GF Knights. Saturday: L/B at EFG - non con Boys South travels to Mandan Friday and BHS on Saturday. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.