This is such a loaded question. They got one piece of hardware; Big Ten regular season champs (I don't know if that accomplishment actually comes with a physical piece of hardware, but I assume so), and had a chance at two more pieces (Big Ten tournament champion and NCAA champion) that they didn't get. Considering the expectations, whether the season was a success could be argued either way forever (and at ad nauseum). If UND were in the same shoes (which they have been in very similar shoes several times), as a fan, I would say no, the season was not successful to meet my satisfaction. But taking out emotion, the pure statistical optics show a very successful season.