I'm not knocking Brock, but Oshie had 45 points in 44 games as a freshman, while Brock had 21 points in 42 games as a freshman. Like yzerman19 said Oshie was special.
The problem is consistency. The last couple years it doesn't seem to matter who's on the schedule or when they're on the schedule our boys can look really good or really bad. I think that's where Berry gets some heat because Hak consistently had the boys playing well the second half of the year.