I really think that this is the biggest question mark I have with the selections. It sucks not to have UND more represented, sure, but it wasn't unforseen. Robbie Earl, however, does not belong where he is. Third team, sure, but second team, no. However, this is based largely on stats. If this was a popularity contest based on stats and sportsmanship, I doubt Earl would even make third team.
Elsworth holds one thing over JPar and Phil that cannot be avoided: More games. Elsworth started a great majority of MTU's games. And, as the record dictates, they stunk. Holding a GAA in the low 3s and a Save% over .9 just shows what kind of a year he's had despite the fact that the team stinks all around him. How would this translate if he were on a team like Minnesota or UND? Not sure, but I'm sure with the numbers he put up and the defenses UND and UMN have, I'm pretty sure that he would have displaced McElhinney as first team AND goalie of the year.
And yes, the WCHA is deep in talent. If Spirko and Genoway were in the CCHA, I'm sure they'd make the top teams of that conference.
As for the rationale behind Spirko vs Zajac vs Pavelski, I defer to the person who accurately speaks for me, PCM.