I've read the comment that a few people have thought +/- seems to be an overrated stat. I'm curious as to why? If you're on the ice when your team is scoring more than when you're getting scored on, especially as a defenseman, you're doing your job. Some defenseman, like Finley, are not big-time offensive defenseman and are not going to put up a bunch of goals and assists. As a coach, the only stat that I cared about was each player's +/-. I could have cared less who had 52 goals and 35 assists.
What stat then, do you think, would tell the whole story, or a better story than +/-?