A couple of thoughts - I would put a lot more stock in the comment about he will never recover if it was coming from a doctor. And ASU really can't say much about the medical condition of a student.
Is there that big of a difference between the E and the A? I don't understand how he can put up such great numbers in the E and mediocre numbers in the A.
What has she done? Does she get credit for St. Thomas joining the league? Since the loss of a national TV contract it is very important to get the schools to improve their broadcasts.