Skippy was not a bit harsh, since h1 fits the name. I missed this run the goalie argument that I started since I ignore h1, but, having looked at the post now, I haven't changed my mind. I didn't care which team won, but the Gopher clearly ran Elliot, which directly resulted in the gwg. There is no way you could construe the Wisco player trying to hold the gopher away from the crease as "pushing him in", unless, of course, like h1, one is wearing maroon glasses.
Edit: Now that I found and watched the utube replay, my description above is incorrect. Carman ran Elliot before the Wisco player made contact, not after.