I think they're all nervous. You would be too, knowing that you're going to get yanked from the start tomorrow if you don't win tonight... That's the way it's been all year. A few years ago, if Karl were to lose on Friday, he'd still be taking shots Saturday night. I don't think our guys have been given the "prove yourself" opportunity that they should've gotten.
IMO a #1 goaltender needed to be picked before the second half of the season started. This flip-switch-change around-hokey pokey BS is killing these guys. Yes, I realize mental toughness is key for a successfull goalie. Well, our goalies all have what seems to be a very fragile psyche, and the "door number 1, 2, or 3 game" is NOT cutting it.
Furthermore, is this affecting the rest of the team? I say yes. You need a comfort zone... and how can you be confident in a different goalie every night?! You won't be...and it's starting to show.