Chevy,
I do not believe that I have bashed J Par. I have said that he has had some poor games, but most recently I have said that Phil is playing better. Without reading my long post again, maybe I was unclear with my comment about not dressing J Par. The way I see it, Phil is the starting goalie and he has outplayed J Par. I also disagree that he has given the team a chance to win in every game. Given that I see Phil as the starter, I do not expect Phil to be given a night off just to give another goalie a chance. We need all the wins we can get, so we need to stick with a hot goalie. I believe that Brandt deserves a chance to play, so it only makes sense to have him on the bench if Phil ever needs to be pulled. Or if Phil has a bad game, start Brandt the next game. If Brandt does not appear to be better than J Par, then bring J Par back. So I was not saying that J Par should never play for the rest of the season, rather that he lost his starting spot and now he needs to compete against Brandt as the back up. I think this information is all clear, and you need to quit putting words in my mouth. The fact that I give my opinion on the order of what string goalie they are says nothing about the quality. If I said I would play Roy, then Belfour, and then CuJo, am I really saying CuJo sucks? I would also take Simbieda over Kollar any day.