Dream Conference for UND
The only way UND should move to Division I is if it can get into a conference of institutions that are similar or complementary in areas of academics, research, alumni support, and are residential campuses. Conferences such as the PAC-10, Big 10, and even the Ivy League define the individual schools just as much the schools define the conference. Smaller Division I conferences are often schizophrenic in their makeup and not especially stable in their membership. The NCC is a higher level conference from this viewpoint than many Div. I conferences.
Six regional schools that would seem most complimentary to UND in their mission, and size are USD, NDSU, SDSU, Univ. of Montana, Montana State, and Univ. of Idaho. They serve as flagship schools in their states, have similar histories, and similar aspirations. Four of them have professional schools: Idaho, Montana, USD, and UND, and four are land grant institutions: Idaho, MSU, NDSU, SDSU. Idaho State or Eastern Washington could be possible eighth members.
The athletic facilites are similar at UND, NDSU, USD, MSU, Idaho State and Idaho, as all have domed stadiums for football. Of all the schools, Idaho has the most advanced athletic program, as it is in Division IA in football. However, from facilities and financial standpoints, Idaho is having difficulty maintaining this level of play and probably would go back to I-AA if it could go back gracefully. They have already stated that returning to the Big Sky is not an option. After Idaho, Boise State, and Nevada left the Big Sky Conference, Montana and Montana State became the strongest anchors for the Big Sky. Both schools would dearly love to have Idaho back as a conference rival and both would probably rather play I-AA UND and NDSU than Sacramento State. If somehow, someway, Montana and Montana State could be convinced that their best interests were to form a new I-AA conference (which would be a huge risk for them as they would lose their chance for an NCAA automatic bid for years) with Idaho and the four NCC schools, UND would be looking at the best possible conference for all sports that could ever be reasonably and responsibly imagined. A Northwestern Conference composed of eight schools would have an incredible cachet, historical significance (Lewis/Clark, trappers/traders, Statehood 1889/1890, east/west railroads/highway, farmers/ranchers, merchants/miners) strong rivalries, reasonable travel (at most two trips across the plains for each sport excluding tournaments), and strengthen natural recruiting tendencies. (The mountain schools look west and the plains schools look east for recruits.) Interest in cities such as Rapid City, Billings, Great Falls, and Bismarck would greatly increase. Most importantly, it would further invigorate all the schools involved by bonding together universities of similar and complementary histories and missions. Such a conference would elevate all schools athletically and, more importantly, academically. It would be a conference worthy of UND pursuing Division I.
The possibility of forming such a conference at the moment is almost nil. But in 2004, when new rules come into effect for IA football, there will most likely be wholesale reshuffling of the lower Division I conferences. That may be the opportune time for a conference change.