I’m not fully sure what you’re trying to say here. I’m not a Homer hater so maybe you’re assuming that? Verhoeff has had some ugly turnover and some moments where he punts it up the ice instead of making a play. Does that mean he should be benched? Nope just learn from it and keep getting better.
Anyways, Seems wise to go with the guy who has had the most consistency and let him learn and keep building. If it becomes a trend for him, then we switch. It’s also easy to forget some of the big saves he made when we were down by 1 to allow us to eventually tie in regulation.